Ok guys, I`ve spent a little time on this topic compiling basically every ban claim post (including friend's of posters) to try to gather some statistics about deletions.
This isn`t perfect, for sure, but this is what we have by now, if someone has any input feel free to add.
209 posts were "analyzed":
- 172 (82,3%) used MC, 15 (7,2%) said they didn`t used. It wasn`t possible to say about the other 22.
- 79 (37,8%) had more than 1 botting char per acc, including 4 posts who had more than 1 botting char but didn`t used MC.
- 70 (33,5%) got high online times (more than 10h per day or on some days).
- 56 (26,8%) were reported by other players, 21 (10%) said for sure they didn't got reported. Many others didn't knew or didn't said anything about it.
- 66 (31,6%) were hunting on popular spawns (salamanders, coryms, OF, etc). 13 (6,2%) was on always empty spawns, including 2 who said they never saw anyone on the spawn, ever.
- 2 were deleted for using the same registration even without botting
- 8 recently came back to play on the acc, 4 of them using MC, other 4 didnt said or said they didnt used MC.
- 6 were good customers, always buying mounts/pacc/etc.
- 3 saw black HP monsters and got deleted, 2 of them when MCing, other one didn't said anything else.
- 1 was deleted when using looting only, but he was using MC while botting another acc too.
- 1 was deleted while using more randomized scripts (random paths) but with not much randomization inside spawn, and also while using MC.
- 3 was deleted for using either healing/only or anti-idle only. 1 of them while using MC for botting other accs, 1 didn't said if was using anything else, and other one said he didn't use anything at all, only 1 client and windbot with anti-idle (most disturbing case)
- NONE said that got deleted while also using Authenticator
Amount of people who didn't MC, didn't bot more than 1 char per acc, didn't get mass reported and didn't play for a high time: SIX (6)
About those 6:
1 was coming back to play after some time and hunted in a popular spawn but didn't got reported
1 was hunting on popular spawn but didn't got reported AND was a good customer
1 was hunting on popular spawn but nothing else
2 had nothing apparently bad, but didn`t said anything about randomization/authenticator
1 was only training with mad sheep with anti-idle (not easy to explain case, maybe deleted on previous acc's and blacklisted)
So, if I can give any advice: Don't MC while botting, only use 1 botting char per acc, don't hunt more than ~4h per day, avoid getting reported, interact with other people, if you are coming back to play don`t jump right into botting hard, always use authenticator (hypothesis not taken down so far), randomize further your waypoints, way of hunting, spawns, talkings with npcs.
If anyone wants I can upload this spreadsheet too, even though it's somewhat rustic and not too friendly.